作业帮一篇GRE短篇阅读,求解读这篇文章的观点和中间两个反问句的含义T T
来源：学生作业帮 编辑：作业帮 分类：英语作业 时间：2024/08/31 20:38:18
一篇GRE短篇阅读,求解读这篇文章的观点和中间两个反问句的含义T T
Both darkly comic and deeply tragic,Guy’s biography of the 12th archbishop of Canterbury Sir Thomas Becket,is a portrait of a saint with plenty of shadows.Does it diminish Becket for us to know that this future martyr in a hair shirt (clothing worn by ascetics) also made sure to keep a fine silk robe handy for his return to Canterbury,a stately progress one chronicler compared to Christ’s entry into Jerusalem?That his abstemious diet was partly the result of a lifelong susceptibility to chronic,and debilitating,indigestion?That one of his oldest and closest friends would have found his canonization “utterly absurd”?Only if we prefer the black-and-white certainties of hagiography to the convincingly human portrayal of a charismatic,contradictory individual who was,as Guy puts it,“as prickly as he was smooth ...a man with the habits of a hedgehog.”作者对Guy的态度是什么?整篇评论是如何展开的...
Both darkly comic and deeply tragic,Guy’s biography of the 12th archbishop of Canterbury Sir Thomas Becket,is a portrait of a saint with plenty of shadows.Does it diminish Becket for us to know that this future martyr in a hair shirt (clothing worn by ascetics) also made sure to keep a fine silk robe handy for his return to Canterbury,a stately progress one chronicler compared to Christ’s entry into Jerusalem?That his abstemious diet was partly the result of a lifelong susceptibility to chronic,and debilitating,indigestion?That one of his oldest and closest friends would have found his canonization “utterly absurd”?Only if we prefer the black-and-white certainties of hagiography to the convincingly human portrayal of a charismatic,contradictory individual who was,as Guy puts it,“as prickly as he was smooth ...a man with the habits of a hedgehog.”作者对Guy的态度是什么?整篇评论是如何展开的...
1.态度：部分肯定.saint正,shadow负评价.Guy是一个复杂的人物,既不是单纯的comic,也不是单纯的tragic.
2.句1,作者观点；句2,设问看做老观点（老观点是正评价）；句3,老观点（中性）；句4,老观点（负评价）；句5,新观点,作者观点.结构总分总,短阅读一般就是总分,这里是末句重新又总结了一下.作者没有单独地去取非老,而是以设问的形式提出老,然后给自己的观点.
3.看末句,only if是限定,一般是否定掉后面的.这里否掉了b and w,否定后是说不能非黑即白,关键词在contradictory和smooth.
2.句1,作者观点；句2,设问看做老观点（老观点是正评价）；句3,老观点（中性）；句4,老观点（负评价）；句5,新观点,作者观点.结构总分总,短阅读一般就是总分,这里是末句重新又总结了一下.作者没有单独地去取非老,而是以设问的形式提出老,然后给自己的观点.
3.看末句,only if是限定,一般是否定掉后面的.这里否掉了b and w,否定后是说不能非黑即白,关键词在contradictory和smooth.