作业帮 > 英语 > 作业

关于虚拟语气的问题看了绣春刀 里面赵公公救了魏廷后大概1个时辰说了一句话:如果不是我,你就被抓住了.字幕的虚拟语气是这样

来源:学生作业帮 编辑:作业帮 分类:英语作业 时间:2024/07/03 07:45:54
关于虚拟语气的问题
看了绣春刀 里面赵公公救了魏廷后大概1个时辰说了一句话:
如果不是我,你就被抓住了.
字幕的虚拟语气是这样的:If it were not for me ,you would be in custody.
可是我觉得应该是与过去事实相反,用:
If it had not been me,you would be in custody.
If it were not for me ,you would be in custody.这句话是对的.因为这是表示与现在相反的状态
意思是 有我你就不会被抓
If it had not been for me,you would have been in custody.这句话是与过去情况相反的状态,与现在没关系.
If it had not been for me,you would be in custody.这是错综虚拟语气,从句与过去相反,主句与现在相反.本句语法也对 ,但意思与原句不一样.
当初如果不是我,你现在就吃牢饭了.
再问: 可是这是赵公公救了魏廷后大概1个时辰说的话啊,不应该用If it had not been for me吗?
再答: 根据你说的情况
应该用If it had not been for me,you would be in custody.